The Functionalist Problem in Kraybill's Riddle of Amish Culture

Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item: https://doi.org/10.18061/1811/81074

Show full item record

Files Size Format View
JAPAS_Billig_vol5-issue1_pp82-95.pdf 65.76Kb PDF View/Open

Title: The Functionalist Problem in Kraybill's Riddle of Amish Culture
Creators: Billig, Michael S.; Zook, Elam
Keywords: Functionalism
Explanation
Riddles
Gelassenheit
Panglossian
Consensus vs. conflict
Issue Date: 2017
Publisher: Ohio State University. Libraries
Citation: Journal of Amish and Plain Anabaptist Studies v. 5, no. 1 (2017), p. 82-95.
Abstract: Much of contemporary Amish scholarship manifests an implicit functionalist paradigm that harkens back to mid-20th-century social science. This perspective tends toward optimistic, even "Panglossian," explanation of traits, in which everything that the Amish do or believe has a use, purpose, or reason; i.e., a function. The vagaries of history and the ebb and flow of power may be acknowledged, but they are relegated to minor explanatory factors. This essay provides a close reading of Donald Kraybill's popular The Riddle of Amish Culture. It demonstrates the functionalist premises behind many of the explanations offered in Riddle, despite the fact that the author provides sufficient information for the reader to come to different conclusions about how aspects of Amish life came to be what they are. That the Amish themselves read and respect Kraybill's work leads to a paradoxical situation in which Kraybill's narratives are taken to be true explanations, which then become another doctrine that must not be debated or self-corrected.
URI: https://doi.org/10.18061/1811/81074
http://hdl.handle.net/1811/81074
ISSN: 2471-6383
Rights: The author retains copyright ownership of this article. Permission to reuse, publish, or reproduce beyond the bounds of Fair Use or other exemptions to copyright law must be obtained from the author.
Bookmark and Share