OSU Navigation Bar

The Ohio State University University Libraries Knowledge Bank

The Knowledge Bank is scheduled for regular maintenance on Sunday, April 20th, 8:00 am to 12:00 pm EDT. During this time users will not be able to register, login, or submit content.

Threat and Performance: Do Upward Social Comparisons Bolster Performance?

Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item: http://hdl.handle.net/1811/51989

Show full item record

Files Size Format View
JulieEyink_Thesis.pdf 307.3Kb PDF View/Open

Title: Threat and Performance: Do Upward Social Comparisons Bolster Performance?
Creators: Eyink, Julie
Advisor: Arkin, Robert
Issue Date: 2012-06
Abstract: This investigation examines how upward social comparisons, comparing oneself to another who is perceived as better than oneself, affects performance. The self-evaluation maintenance model states that if a person is threatened by another in a certain domain, he may withdraw effort from that domain and then refocus on a different domain where he can outperform the other person (Tesser 1988). For this investigation, we used Johnson and Stapel’s (2007a, 2007b) procedure. Participants read about a successful student (either a freshman, senior, or a freshman with a disability) in either a verbal or science domain. Participants who read about a freshman, either with or without a disability, felt the freshman’s successes were unattainable on the same timetable. If a person does not believe he can achieve the same things as his comparison target, he feels threatened (Lockwood & Kunda, 1997). Participants then took the Remote Associates Task (RAT), a test of verbal and creative abilities. We found support for Tesser’s SEM model, such that participants who read about the science successful student and took the RAT (mismatched domains of comparison and testing) answered more RAT items correctly than participants who read about the verbal successful student (matched domains). Implications for using social comparisons in a beneficial manner and future directions of research are discussed.
Embargo: No embargo
Series/Report no.: The Ohio State University. Department of Psychology Honors Theses; 2012
Keywords: social comparison
self evaluation maintenance model
performance
threat
URI: http://hdl.handle.net/1811/51989
Bookmark and Share